| Team | Round 1 |
| Badnewz | 1.1 Yoshinobu Yamamoto (LAD - SP) |
| Loveable Losers | 1.2 Paul Skenes (Pit - SP) |
| Name TBD | 1.3 Wyatt Langford (Tex - OF) |
| Hair Of The Dog Fred | 1.4 Dylan Crews (Was - OF) |
| Blame It on Rijo | 1.5 Jung Hoo Lee (SF - OF) |
| The Judgesicles | 1.6 Anthony Volpe (NYY - SS) |
| Third Day | 1.7 Eury Perez (Mia - SP) |
| Squeeze Play | 1.8 Shane Bieber (Cle - SP) |
| Slimedog | 1.9 Ethan Salas (SD - C) |
| Mexico City Aztecs | 1.10 Jose Alvardo (Phi - RP) |
| Chevy Chase Coopers | 1.11 Jace Jung (Det - 2B) |
| Tenth Man Out | 1.12 Walker Jenkins (Min - OF) |
| Team | Round 2 |
| Badnewz | 2.1 Cole Ragans (KC - SP,RP) |
| Loveable Losers | 2.2 Brandon Pfaadt (Ari - SP) |
| Name TBD | 2.3 AJ Smith-Shawver (Atl - SP) |
| Hair Of The Dog Fred | 2.4 Marco Luciano (SF - SS) |
| Blame It on Rijo | 2.5 Jarren Duran (Bos - OF) |
| The Judgesicles | 2.6 J.D. Martinez (LAA - OF) |
| Third Day | 2.7 Lane Thomas (Was - OF) |
| Squeeze Play | 2.8 Jarred Kelenic (Atl - OF) |
| Slimedog | 2.9 Reese Olsen (Det - SP) |
| Mexico City Aztecs | 2.10 Alex Kirilloff (Min - 1B,OF) |
| Chevy Chase Coopers | 2.11 Vaughn Grissom (Bos - 2B, SS) |
| Tenth Man Out | 2.12 Conner Phillips (Cin - SP) |
| Team | Round 3 |
| Badnewz | 3.1 Max Meyer (Mia - SP) |
| Loveable Losers | 3.2 Logan O'Hoppe (LAA - C) |
| Name TBD | 3.3 Alex Lange (Det - RP) |
| Hair Of The Dog Fred | 3.4 Shota Imanaga (ChC - SP) |
| Blame It on Rijo | 3.5 Robert Suarez (SD - RP) |
| The Judgesicles | 3.6 Garrett Crochet (ChW - RP) |
| Third Day | 3.7 Chris Sale (Atl - SP) |
| Squeeze Play | 3.8 Jordan Hicks (SF - SP) |
| Slimedog | 3.9 Heston Kjerstad (Bal - OF) |
| Mexico City Aztecs | 3.10 James Paxton (Bos - SP) |
| Chevy Chase Coopers | 3.11 Kerry Carpenter (Det - OF) |
| Tenth Man Out | 3.12 Ceddanne Rafaela (Bos - SS,OF) |
| Team | Round 4 |
| Badnewz | 4.1 Andy Pages (LAD - OF) |
| Loveable Losers | 4.2 Sixto Sanchez (Mia - SP) |
| Name TBD | 4.3 Andrés Giménez (Cle - 2B) |
| Hair Of The Dog Fred | 4.4 Max Clark (Det - OF) |
| Blame It on Rijo | 4.5 Kutter Crawford (Bos - P) |
| The Judgesicles | 4.6 Liover Peguero (Pit - 2B,SS) |
| Third Day | 4.7 Zach Neto (LAA - SS) |
| Squeeze Play | 4.8 Christopher Morel (ChC - 2B, OF) |
| Slimedog | 4.9 Chris Paddack (Min - SP) |
| Mexico City Aztecs | 4.10 Parker Meadows (Det - OF) |
| Chevy Chase Coopers | 4.11 Kenta Maeda (Det - SP) |
| Tenth Man Out | 4.12 Hurston Waldrep (Atl - SP) |
| Team | Round 5 |
| Badnewz | 5.1 Orelvis Martinez (Tor - 2B,3B,SS) |
| Loveable Losers | 5.2 Luisangel Acuña (NYM - 2B,SS) |
| Name TBD | 5.3 Kevin Alcantara (ChC - OF) |
| Hair Of The Dog Fred | 5.4 Jonathan Aranda (TB - 1B) |
| Blame It on Rijo | 5.5 Dominic Fletcher (Ari - OF) |
| The Judgesicles | 5.6 Christian Mena (CHW - SP) |
| Third Day | 5.7 Sam Bachman (LAA - SP) |
| Squeeze Play | 5.8 Colt Keith (Det - 3B) |
| Slimedog | 5.9 Will Smith (KC - RP) |
| Mexico City Aztecs | 5.10 Drew Thorpe (SD - SP) |
| Chevy Chase Coopers | 5.11 Wander Franco (TB - SS) |
| Tenth Man Out | 5.12 Luken Baker (Stl - 1B) |
